Why 1 Corinthians 15:22 does not teach universalism

The Meme on Facebook asked its readers to help him understand how “in Adam all die” refers to everyone, but “in Christ all shall be made alive” does not. It asked who changed the meaning of “all.”

My response:

The answer to the question is the Apostle Paul, when he wrote the words “in Christ.” That prepositional phrase governs the meaning of “all” in that part of the sentence. All means everyone in Christ, just as the previous part of the sentence refers to everyone in Adam.

You would have thought I had shot God.

What followed was a series of replies, each politely telling me I don’t know what I am talking about. They insist that ALL means ALL.

The best argument is not to try to explain that ἐν τῷ Χριστῷ is a prepositional phrase describing those who will be made alive because of their relationship to Christ.

The strongest argument appears to be contextual rather than lexical. In other words, the meaning of “all” (πάντες) is controlled by Paul’s resurrection argument in 1 Corinthians 15, not by the phrase ἐν τῷ Χριστῷ considered in isolation.

That distinction matters, because πάντες carries no fixed quantity of its own. It takes its scope from the sentence and from the argument in which it stands. Paul himself qualifies an “all” inside this very chapter (15:27), and he does it without apology.

The Immediate Context (1 Cor 15:20-23)

Paul writes:

20 Νυνὶ δὲ Χριστὸς ἐγήγερται ἐκ νεκρῶν
23 ἕκαστος δὲ ἐν τῷ ἰδίῳ τάγματι· ἀπαρχὴ Χριστός, ἔπειτα οἱ τοῦ Χριστοῦ ἐν τῇ παρουσίᾳ αὐτοῦ

Notice what Paul does immediately after saying:

“For as in Adam all die, so also in Christ all will be made alive.”

He explains who the resurrected “all” are:

“after that those who are Christ’s at His coming.”

Verse 23 functions as an interpretation of verse 22. The people made alive “in Christ” are identified as οἱ τοῦ Χριστοῦ (“those who are Christ’s”), not all humanity indiscriminately.

If Paul intended universal salvation, verse 23 would be a strange and unnecessary restriction.

The sequence in the paragraph does the work. Paul has just called Christ the firstfruits of those who have fallen asleep, the first sheaf of a harvest that guarantees the rest of the field. Then he says that each will rise in his own order, a word for ranks or divisions in an ordered body. Paul is not describing two harvests with two populations. He is describing one harvest, gathered in ranks, from the first fruits to those who are Christ’s at His coming, and then to the end, when the kingdom is handed over to the Father (15:24).

If πάντες in verse 22 reached every human being without exception, verse 23 would have to say “then everyone,” and the qualifier “at His coming” would lose its point.

The Parallelism Is Corporate, Not Numerical

Universalists often assume the verse means:

  • All humanity in Adam = every human being.
  • Therefore all humanity in Christ = every human being.

But Paul’s wording does not require that.

The parallel can be understood as:

  • Everyone who is in Adam dies.
  • Everyone who is in Christ lives.

The emphasis falls on the two realms or corporate heads.

Paul uses this kind of representative language elsewhere:

  • Adam represents the old humanity.
  • Christ represents the new humanity.

The “all” in each clause is naturally limited by the sphere in which it occurs.

Thus:

πάντες ἐν τῷ Ἀδὰμ
“all who are in Adam”

versus

πάντες ἐν τῷ Χριστῷ
“all who are in Christ”

The second group is not coextensive with the first.

The same pattern appears in Paul’s longest treatment of the two heads. In Romans 5:12 he says that “death spread to all men, because all sinned.” A few sentences later he calls the same group “the many” who died (5:15) and “the many” who will be appointed righteous (5:19). The “all” of verse 18 and the “many” of verse 19 describe one group, a whole body sharing the destiny of its head. Paul does the same in 1 Corinthians 15:45-49. “The first man, Adam, became a living soul. The last Adam became a life-giving spirit,” and the conclusion is not that everyone bears the image of the heavenly, but that “just as we have borne the image of the earthy, we will also bear the image of the heavenly” (15:49). The “we” there is the church.

The phrase “in Adam” occurs only here in the New Testament. “In Christ” occurs again and again, and it always has an entrance: faith, baptism, His body.

Paul’s Normal Usage of “In Christ”

Throughout Paul’s letters, being “in Christ” is never a universal human condition.

Examples:

  • “There is therefore now no condemnation for those in Christ Jesus” (Rom 8:1).
  • “If anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation” (2 Cor 5:17).
  • “You are all sons of God through faith in Christ Jesus” (Gal 3:26).

For Paul, union with Christ belongs to believers. The phrase never describes the entire human race irrespective of faith.

Therefore, it would be highly unusual for Paul suddenly to use ἐν τῷ Χριστῷ in 1 Corinthians 15:22 as though every human without exception were already united to Christ.

Two more witnesses. In Ephesians 1:3 God “has blessed us with every spiritual blessing in the heavenly places in Christ,” and in 1:10 His purpose is “the summing up of all things in Christ.” Even where Christ’s headship is as wide as creation, the blessing is located in Him. And Paul tells us how a person comes to be there: “For all of you who were baptized into Christ have clothed yourselves with Christ” (Gal 3:27). The phrase has an entrance.

A preposition that marks union cannot be read as though it marked mere membership in the race. If “in Christ” meant “human,” Paul’s longing to be found in Him would be nonsense.

The Resurrection in View Is Resurrection unto Glory

The chapter is not discussing merely resurrection from the dead.

Everyone, righteous and wicked, will be raised (cf. John 5:28-29). But Paul is arguing for the resurrection of believers and their victory over death.

The sequence is:

  1. Christ raised.
  2. Those who belong to Christ are raised.
  3. The kingdom is consummated.

The chapter never discusses the resurrection of unbelievers.

Therefore, “made alive” (ζῳοποιηθήσονται) is best understood as participation in the resurrection life of Christ, not simply reanimation.

The verb settles it. Paul uses ζῳοποιέω for the life that the Spirit gives, not for the restoration of a corpse. In Romans 8:11, the Spirit who raised Christ “will also give life to your mortal bodies.” In 2 Corinthians 3:6, “the letter kills, but the Spirit gives life.” In 15:45, the last Adam is “a life-giving spirit,” and 15:22 uses that same verb. To be made alive in this chapter is to receive the body Paul has just described, sown a natural body and raised a spiritual body (15:42-44).

This is why the universalist reading would not even deliver what universalists want. If πάντες meant every human being without exception, the verse would teach that every human being is raised in glory, which is not the resurrection of judgment that John 5:29 assumes. The verse would prove too much.

The Decisive Argument

In my judgment, the strongest single argument is:

Verse 23 defines the “all” of verse 22 as “those who belong to Christ.”

Paul says:

πάντες … ζωοποιηθήσονται (v.22)

and then immediately explains:

ἔπειτα οἱ τοῦ Χριστοῦ ἐν τῇ παρουσίᾳ αὐτοῦ (v.23)

Thus the flow of thought is:

  • In Adam, all die.
  • In Christ, all will be made alive.
  • That is, those who belong to Christ will be raised at His coming.

For that reason, most non-universalist commentators understand 1 Corinthians 15:22 not as teaching universal salvation, but as teaching the certainty that every person united to Christ will share Christ’s resurrection life.

Here is the principle behind that judgment. When an author defines his own term in the next sentence, the definition wins. We do not set the explanatory clause aside in favor of an English word’s abstract range. Verse 22 raises the question of scope; verse 23 answers it.

Paul shows how he handles an “all” inside the same paragraph. In 15:27 he quotes the psalm about all things being put in subjection under Christ’s feet, then adds that the One who put all things in subjection is obviously excepted. He will qualify an “all” as soon as he has spoken it.

So nobody changed the meaning of “all.” The word never had a meaning apart from its context. “All” in a sentence about a cup is not “all” in a sentence about an ocean. Here the context is a resurrection chapter, and the two “alls” are bounded by the two men in whom they stand. In Adam, all die. In Christ, all will be made alive, that is, everyone who is Christ’s at His coming.

lessons in appreciation

IMG-1001

“…appreciate those who diligently labor among you” (1 Thessalonians 5:12 NASB).

It was cold that morning when we woke up. We had driven for hours the previous day so we could see the beautiful Fall colors of the Blue Ridge Mountains. We stayed overnight at the Appalachian Advent Christian Campground at Blowing Rock. I was destined for some lessons in appreciation that weekend. My first lesson came as we enjoyed breakfast with the camp caretakers – Rob and Pam Buchanan. It was such a treat to spend time with those wonderful people. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, we had not had much time together with other couples in ministry.

But we had been determined to see some Autumn leaves, so we tore ourselves away, and went back to the Blue Ridge Parkway. It seemed that everyone else on the planet had the same idea that day. We shared our hike in the mountains with a lot of other sightseers. It was still magnificent.

As we returned to our car for lunch at an overlook on the Parkway, we discovered a dead battery. Our key fob did not work for the car doors, and the key only worked for the trunk. So, I could only open the doors by emptying the trunk and crawling through a small square panel into the back seat.

Then we could get into the car, but the battery was still dead. We have a AAA membership, but it would have taken hours for a service vehicle to go through the bumper-to-bumper traffic to get to us. There were thousands of people flowing through the parkway, so, even though our phones had no signal, it was not long before we found a willing stranger to pull out his jumper cables, and give us a boost. That was another appreciation lesson.

IMG-0998Lots of Advent Christians celebrate pastor appreciation month in October. It is very encouraging to get a postcard, or a greeting card with words of appreciation from members of one’s congregation. I have also been using this month for another kind of pastor’s appreciation. During the announcements, I have been mentioning people with prominent ministries in our congregation, sometimes praying for them.

At the worship service yesterday, the congregation presented me with a gift. It was one of those portable battery boosters that we can carry with us – just in case we need a boost again. I really appreciate these folks.

the message is ministry

IMG_0203The word gospel is usually translated “good news.” It can also be translated “excellent message.” I like that translation because it helps me to realise how important sharing the message about Christ is. There are any number of good things I can do for others as part of my ministry.  But the most important thing is to get this excellent message to them.

Mark started his Gospel with the words “This is the beginning of that excellent message about Jesus Christ (1:1).” From then on, any biography of Jesus was called a Gospel. But Mark was not using the word to indicate a new literary genre.[1] He was talking about the unique message about Jesus that John the Baptist started preaching, and he was essentially saying “now here’s my take on that excellent message.” It is like Mark was also challenging me to write a Gospel according to Jefferson Vann. Of course, I was not there to write the beginning of the message, but that message has impacted me, so I get to help pass it on.

Jesus himself preached that excellent message, and commanded others to believe it (1:14-15). To believe the message is to believe in Christ himself. You haven’t really repented unless you do. To believe that message is to take up your cross and have your soul put to death for it (8:34-35). It is worth leaving your family behind for (10:29). It’s worth more than simply liking it when someone posts it on a social network. It’s worth giving everything for.

The mission of reaching the nations with this message is so important that Jesus promises not to come back to earth until it is done (13:10). All those stories in the New Testament will be told to the whole world (14:9; 16:15) as a witness to everyone of the impact that Jesus had when he came to visit this little planet. The message includes what Jesus did and what he taught his followers to do. So, each generation needs to ask whether we are doing things that spread the message or stifle it.

Each church needs to ask a similar question. Lots of things are being done, and money spent on “missions” projects that have little to do with giving the excellent message to those who have not heard it. We used to invest lots of money in these strange animals that we called missionaries. The missionaries would leave their home country and invest themselves in the lives of people in another culture in order to get the message into that culture, and establish proclamation posts (churches) in that target culture. I know that still can happen. I am a missionary myself. But the club is not a very popular one in this generation.

Now, I know I’m being simplistic. Ministry in the name of Jesus is more than just sharing the message about Jesus. When the world looks at a church which just preaches, they see a museum exhibit with a caption underneath “archaic and soon to be extinct.” We owe it to our neighbours to love them as we love ourselves, which will mean feeding them when they are hungry, and helping them heal when they are broken. There is a lot of ministry that we can do, and we should do in the name of Christ. I think the pendulum has begun to swing back in the direction of serving others in this generation, and that is a good thing. But we should not lose sight of the message completely as we minister. The message is ministry.


[1] R.T. France, The Gospel of Mark: A Commentary on the Greek Text. (Grand Rapids: Wm B. Eerdmans Publishing, 2002), 4.